21 October 2026

I am sure you have heard of the investment cycle. The economic cycle. Even the bicycle. But have you heard of the embarrassment cycle? It is where something starts off being deeply embarrassing. A few brave souls give it a go. Others follow. Before long everyone is doing it.
Take mobile phones. When they first came out you looked like an idiot using one. Now people wander down the street talking loudly to themselves. Nobody bats an eyelid. Online dating was once something you kept quiet about. Now it is where half the country meets its future spouse. Weight-loss injections were once whispered about. Now they are discussed openly over dinner. Usually by someone who isn’t eating very much.
The thing itself hasn’t necessarily changed. What has changed is how many other people are doing it. Once enough people join in, the embarrassment disappears. Eventually, it’s the people who aren’t doing it who feel like the odd ones out.
Why? Because we care enormously what others think. Nobody likes being the odd one out. Or looking stupid. And nowhere is this more entertaining to watch than on The Traitors. Strip away the castle and cloaks and you have an experiment in human behaviour. People trying desperately not to look foolish. And consequently, making fools of themselves.
Someone decides Nigel is a Traitor because he looked shifty over breakfast. By lunchtime it’s a theory. By dinner, established fact. His choice of cereal is examined. His failure to make eye contact is damning. Making eye contact is worse. Poor Nigel hasn’t a chance.
Others agree. Disagreeing means standing out. And standing out means you might be next. Soon everyone is voting for Nigel. Including, quite possibly, Nigel. When he turns out innocent, there is brief embarrassment. Then everyone moves on to Susan.
Investment markets behave similarly. We have theories. Find supporting evidence. Become convinced. And feel reassured when everyone agrees. Fund managers are particularly prone to this. Owning the same shares as everyone else is comforting. If things go wrong, at least you have company.
Buying an unpopular share is different. If it falls, you look foolish. Nobody to hide behind. It’s like writing a name on the chalkboard at The Traitors round table knowing nobody else will write the same one down. So, investors wait until an idea becomes fashionable. By then though much of the opportunity has disappeared.
The embarrassment cycle again. Nobody wants to own it. A few brave souls buy. The price rises. Others follow. Eventually everyone wants it. And those who don’t? Now they feel embarrassed. The reverse happens too. Yesterday’s fashionable investment becomes today’s embarrassment. Just ask shareholders in spirit companies, Diageo, Pernod and Rémy Cointreau. Suddenly nobody admits owning them.
At MVAM we know we aren’t really different from anyone else. Perhaps that is The Traitors’ greatest lesson. However clever we think we are, we all make the same mistakes. Recognising this though might actually be an advantage. We don’t have some magical ability to see what everybody else has missed. We just try to recognise when we’re following the crowd because the evidence makes sense, and when we’re following it because standing somewhere else feels uncomfortable.
It doesn’t mean we automatically disagree with the crowd. Sometimes they are right. Even on The Traitors, they occasionally find a Traitor. It means being prepared to look foolish. And admitting when we actually are. There is a difference between conviction and stubbornness. One is based on evidence. The other on embarrassment. In investing, as in The Traitors, it’s very easy to mix the two up. On the game show you banish someone. In the investment world you lose money.
With that I’m off to the pub for an Aperol Spritz. Now everyone’s drinking them, it’s time to publicly admit I quite like them. Much better than drinking them alone in my kitchen.